Quantum entanglement in bent space

Between gravity and the quantum world

31. January 2024 by Dorian Schiffer
Physicists in the team of Philip Walther at the University of Vienna investigate how gravity works in the bizarre realm of quantum physics. Watch the video for a glimpse into their lab and their ambitions and read on to learn about a new precision experiment on the influence of gravity on quantum entanglement.
The Walther Lab is dedicated to investigating the fundamental principles of quantum physics. "My research serves a dual purpose – to provide new insights into quantum phenomena and to contribute to the development of advanced quantum technologies for various applications," says Philip Walther. In this video, he also shares his perspective on the curious minds of scientists and an advice for young researchers. © Franz Quitt

It is often at the boundaries where things get exciting: They offer space for exchange, tension – but also conflict. And while we are used to boundaries in the outside world, it is surprising that the world of physics is also divided into two parts.

On the one hand, there is the sphere of quantum theory, which has gone from one success to the next since its development a good 120 years ago: From the most volatile particles to the glow of stars, physicists use quantum physics to describe an impressive range of phenomena.

Seemingly separate from this world, there is also the realm of gravity, which forces planets, gas nebulae and galaxies into their orbits. Both theories are an integral part of modern physics. There is only one problem: Gravity and quantum physics do not go well together.

Looking for the link

This fact rankles physicists like Philip Walther. "We are actually looking for a theory that describes everything," says the Professor of Quantum Physics at the University of Vienna. "That is why it is interesting to see how the two fundamentally different theories interact.”

But that is not so easy, because gravity and quantum physics do usually not get in each other's way: At large masses and high energies, quantum effects are negligible, just as, conversely, weak gravity usually plays no role in the microcosm.

Only recently, and thanks to state-of-the-art experiments, have researchers analysed the effects at the boundaries of the two hemispheres of physics. There are two ways to see the effects of gravity on quantum systems: "Either we achieve extremely high precision, or we work with larger masses," says Walther.

Photon test object

Walther and his team are pursuing the first approach: "We are working with massless particles, and therefore directly within the scope of Albert Einstein's general theory of relativity," says the physicist. Massless – this is where photons, the particles of light, come into play. As Einstein's formulae show, photons have no (resting) mass.

In fact, light is the most prominent inhabitant of the border area between gravity and quantum physics: Although individual photons are quantum objects, they experience the influence of gravity when they whizz around clusters of galaxies on curved paths in space, for example.

For Walther, an expert in quantum states of light, photons are therefore the ideal object of research – especially as their interaction with gravity can only be correctly described using the general theory of relativity and not Newton's law of gravity, which is already obsolete today.

Together with gravitational physicist Piotr Chruściel from the University of Vienna, Walther will investigate exactly how gravity and photons interact as part of the international GRAVITES project, which also involves research groups from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) and the University of Munich.

 

Artist's impression of a light quantum experiment in space time
With the GRAVITES project, Philipp Walther and his team want to show for the first time that the laws of Einstein's general relativity also apply in the quantum world. The expected effects are so minimal that the measurements must achieve maximum precision. An optical interferometer is used for this purpose. Here is an artist's impression of the experiment in warped spacetime. © Walther Group

Precise measurements

At the heart of the project, which was recently awarded an ERC Synergy Grant worth almost nine million euros, will be a fibre optic interferometer that will measure the influence of gravity on entangled photons over a total length of 50 to 100 kilometres.

This is a set-up in which an entangled pair of photons has two paths of equal length at its disposal, which reunite at the end. The trick is that one of the paths will lie above the other. As the force of gravity becomes weaker with increasing distance from the Earth, the paths through the interferometer are exposed to different gravitational influences.

This difference in gravity should be noticeable in a change in the entanglement state of the photons. But: "This prediction has not yet been tested," says Walther. According to the physicist, the planned interferometer could be used to experimentally investigate the influence of gravity on quantum entanglement – one of the key characteristics of quantum physics – for the first time and possibly detect deviations. "That would be particularly exciting, of course."

Interferometers

... are indispensable devices in quantum physics. They consist of two paths a quantum system can take, in which different conditions are prevailing. For example, one path might lead through a strong magnetic field or close by a large mass. The influence of these forces results in a phase difference between the waves, with which physicists describe quantum systems. This results in an interference, i.e. the mutual amplification or extinction of waves, when their paths are combined again. This way, even the weakest influence on the systems can be shown.

Entanglement

... occurs when two quantum systems behave as if they were one system. This manifests itself, for example, in correlations that exist between measurement results on entangled pairs and that cannot be explained by the properties of the individual partner systems. The secret behind entanglement is still highly controversial among physicists and philosophers alike. What we certainly know, however, is that this phenomenon can be used as a resource, for example for the tap-proof distribution of digital keys or in quantum computers.

Highly challenging research

The precision required for this is a huge technical challenge: The interferometer must be shielded against thermal fluctuations, vibrations and other interference and the length of the arms must be actively stabilised. Following the remodelling of the Faculty of Physics, the experiment will even have its own room, which will be decoupled from the environment as far as possible.

This will create the most sensitive experiment of its kind on a laboratory scale. However, the ability to precisely manipulate light quanta – and potential technical spin-offs – are only a pleasant side effect for the experts. Their focus is on measuring this mysterious border area between gravity and quantum physics.

© Barbara Mair
© Barbara Mair
Philip Walther is Professor of Physics at the University of Vienna. Following his diploma studies in Chemistry, Walther changed his research interest and obtained his doctoral degree in Physics supervised by Anton Zeilinger. After several years of research at Harvard University, he moved back to Vienna.

He studies quantum states of light, which he uses to build quantum computers, implement tap-proof communication protocols and investigate the links between gravity and quantum physics. Walther has been honoured with numerous awards for his work, including the Fresnel Prize of the European Physical Society, the START Prize of the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) and the Friedrich Wilhelm Bessel Research Award of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation. Walther is currently the spokesperson for the quantum group at the University of Vienna and for the inter-institutional research network "Quantum Aspects of Space Time (TURIS)".